Police Officer Hired Hitman to Kill Her Husband and a Young Girl

Surviving a Broken Marriage

Sometimes marriages end, even when they have the most promising beginnings. Despite vows being taken and the promise of “’til death do us part,” people can change and fall out of love.

However, what happens when that love turns to hate so strong, even divorce won’t remedy it?

Hoping for a New Life

For Isaiah Carvalho Jr., divorce meant the start of a new life away from his estranged wife Linda, a New York City police officer.

However, Isaiah was about to get the shock of his life…Linda had been plotting a horrible fate for him…

A Devastating Truth

In fact, for over five months, Valerie Cincinelli had been plotting with her boyfriend to hire a hitman to murder both her soon-to-be ex-husband and her new boyfriend’s daughter. 

This story is too horrific to believe. A tale of corruption, anger, and pure vengeance…

Four Years Ago

Both Isaiah and Linda had married in 2015, thinking they would spend the rest of their lives together. 

Linda was a successful police officer and Isaiah was a machine operator who sold fireworks on the side. Together, they seemed like a match made in heaven.

Happy for A Time

The couple seemed quite happy at first. Although Linda’s job did provide a fair share of stress, the newlyweds managed to work through it. 

Unfortunately, things took a turn for the worse.

The Marriage Goes South

Four years into the marriage, Linda decided to call it quits and move on with another man. What followed was a very messy divorce, that involved mediation and a lengthy custody battle for their two children. 

However, after five months of hell, Isaiah thought the matter had resolved itself.

A Sinister Plot

Linda had other plans. In fact, she hatched a diabolical scheme that would involve hiring someone to kill Isaiah and her new boyfriend’s daughter. 

Linda wanted to start fresh and felt the only way to do so would be to eliminate them both.

The Boyfriend Caught in the Middle

Linda’s new boyfriend was caught in the middle of the scheme. He loved Linda but knew that a murder-for-hire plot wouldn’t be successful. 

Realizing she could use her powers within the NYPD to make it happen, he quickly contacted the FBI.

The FBI Gets Involved

After revealing Linda’s plans to the FBI, it was decided that the boyfriend would see how far Linda would go with her plans. 

He would be the eyes and ears of the FBI with the plan to catch her in the act.

An Idea Planted

Despite her boyfriend’s initial objections, Linda wouldn’t take no for an answer. 

After the custody battle with her ex, she would not let him get away with taking her two children or humiliating her in court. Therefore, he needed to die.

Using Her Expertise

Linda had been exposed to homicides over the course of her career at the NYPD. She knew how killers were caught and that it would be in their best interest to hire someone to do it. 

They couldn’t have any trails leading the murders back to them.

Two Horrific Deaths

The boyfriend couldn’t imagine life without his own daughter. And while he knew that Linda’s divorce had been a messy affair, murder seemed to be a bit extreme. However, he realized she was set on having them dead. Nothing would change her mind.

Linda’s plan was simple, they would make her ex-husband’s death look like an accident and then the killer would run over her boyfriend’s daughter outside of her school.

A Nightmare Scenario

For Linda’s boyfriend, it was a scene out of a horror movie. And when Isaiah was informed of the murderous plot, he was beside himself. 

“It’s your worst nightmare scenario,” said Matthew Weiss, Mr. Carvalho’s lawyer.

Divorce Can Be Deadly

Isaiah believes the divorce hit his Linda hard. She had run into trouble with the NYPD in the past and combined with her marriage troubles, it seemed she had finally snapped.

If only he knew how bad things actually were…

Hire the Hitman

After five months of planning and the FBI tracking the situation, Linda was finally ready to make her move. 

She instructed her boyfriend to hire the killer but was very specific on how he should be paid.

A Payment of Gold

Linda’s boyfriend revealed he was instructed to withdraw $7,000 from the bank and to purchase the same amount in gold coins.

This would be the easiest and least trackable way to pay the killer.

Stalking Her Daughter

Meanwhile, Linda used social media to track her boyfriend’s daughter and learn her routine. She wanted to know the girl’s every move so the hitman could do his job properly. 

Everything needed to be planned perfectly for the murders to proceed without any complications.

Wired and Ready

Finally, on May 13, 2019, Linda called her boyfriend and asked him to meet her to discuss the hits in detail. 

Wearing a wire, he met with her, hoping the FBI could finally get the evidence needed to take her down.

Don’t Get Caught

After meeting up with Linda, the boyfriend stressed to her that the murder plot was too complicated and they would definitely get caught. 

However, Linda assured him she knew a way to make sure the murders didn’t seem linked.

Two Days, Two Murders

According to Linda, the murders would take place on two different days. Her ex-husband would be taken out in an area she described as “ghetto” therefore, no one would suspect any foul play. 

As for his daughter, it would be a tragic hit and run…a complete fluke. No one would be the wiser.

Authorities At Work

After the meeting, the FBI decided it was in their best interest to convince Linda that the murders had actually taken place in order to catch her. 

They asked the boyfriend if he was willing to continue with the charade and he agreed. He wanted to see this cold-blooded monster put away for good.

Convincing the Monster

Pretending to be her boyfriend, the FBI texted Linda to let her know that her plot had succeeded. 

They contacted her at home and told her they were investigating the death of her ex-husband Isaiah. However, they also chose to take things a step further. You won’t believe the lengths they went to…

Faking A Death

The authorities pretended to be the killer as well! 

They sent Linda fake crime scene photos, hoping to convince her that the disgusting deed had been done. Thankfully, she took the bait.

The Deed is Done

Thrilled that the murder had been successful, Linda immediately contacted her boyfriend with the news. 

She wanted to make sure they aligned their alibis so there would no red flags if they were questioned by the police.

Erasing the Evidence

Texting her boyfriend (who actually was an FBI agent), Linda demanded he deleted all of their text message conversations. 

It was imperative they left no tangible trail that could link them to the crime.

Taken Into Custody

With all of the evidence they needed, the FBI approached Linda that afternoon and arrested her.

To say Linda was shocked was an understatement. The officer had been outsmarted by the man she thought loved her.

Officially Charged

Linda was booked at the NYPD and charged with the use of interstate commerce for murder for hire.

It was a mighty fall from grace for the officer…or was it?

A History of Misconduct

It seemed Linda had a history of misconduct during her career with the NYPD. After joining the force in 2007, she had worked at the 106th Precinct in Queens as a domestic violence officer until 2017. 

However, she was placed on modified duty after sharing confidential information with her boyfriend. She also lost the right to carry a gun.

Why Murder?

So what brought this officer to murder? The FBI can’t say for sure, but they believe her tumultuous love life had something to do with it. 

Isaiah Carvalho had been her second husband, and she had restraining orders against her first husband.

The Investigation Continues

As of now, Linda is being held without bail as the investigation continues. “There is very strong evidence of guilt of the crimes of trying to get these two individuals murdered,” said Judge Anne Y. Shields of the federal court in the Eastern District.

We hope justice is served and we’re thankful that both Isaiah and the innocent girl escaped with their lives. Love can be a dangerous thing…